It's true that you need to know what the problem is. But if the room is fighting the speakers, things can't sound right. And that's a fact. If rooms didn't matter, then why design a recording studio? Why not use any old space? This is not up for argument. The question becomes, how much money and time do I want to spend?
Almost without exception, the most neglected part of most sound systems is the room treatment. I have to believe that speaker manufacturers like Acoustic Research, Advent, Klipsch and B&W (to name only a few), have had people with exceptional hearing "test" or listen to their products and be completely satisfied or even amazed with their performance. Why, because they have perfect listening enviorments! We the people then go out and buy these speakers and an assortment of related and necessary equipment to feed them sound. After that, there is years of swapping speakers, amps, preamps, CD players, turntables and boutique wire in an attempt to squeeze out a little better performance. I wonder how many pieces of perfectly good pieces of equipment I sold becuse they were at war with the room.
Most of us, probably because of aesthetics or WAF, avoid treating the room. It's a tough pill to swallow.
I too am guilty as charged.
Well, thanks for the posting this thread and a special thanks for the link. It's high time that I practice what the hell I preach.
The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our equipment, but in our rooms....