Interesting... I'll admit that when I read your above comment (and the associated CD's with it) the first thought through my head was... "well, aren't the 'audiophile' (with the fancy words & descriptions) doing the same thing? Perhaps not... but that's kind of my take on it. Meaning... take those same CD's and put it through the two speaker brands mentioned in the beginning.... which one is now the reference standard for those same CD's? I wonder if the reference standard can change depending on which CD is in... then how can it really be the reference standard?
Another take is, how can Coke and Diet Sprite be a reference standard of the same catagory?
Furthermore...regarding the comments about leathery wine & such... I'm not a wine person, but it seems to me that each sip of wine is of itself, an 'original' experience. We however, are talking about a reproduction of an event so in the case of wine... each sip is "reality" but reality in the recorded world is what happened when the note was first made, no?
I realize that if made in the studio, you then have additional influences of all the gyrations the signal might go through from string pluck to mixer board etc.. then to CD or LP creation.
Richard---
Now you are getting there. The "musical reality" was a guy playing his violin in some 3D space and the listener who heard it at that moment. Whatever happens AFTER that such as using mics to convert pressure to electricity and storing it for later processing and then on to a disc, is NOT THE MUSIC. What is on that disc has never been heard as a musical event - - only an electrical event later on in the mixing room. And unless you have that room, with those speakers and gear, you will not hear what the mixer put on that CD - period. And whatever IS on that disc, is NOT the 3D reality of the guy bowing his violin in a space. Where does that leave you?
We should all remember the famous demonstration when Paul Klipsch had Khorns behind the curtain with a symphony orchestra in front. When the musicians put down their instruments in the middle of the performance, walked away, and the curtain was raised revealing the sound source the people were astonished.
Thats good enough for me!
Don