Greetings, TVodhanel... I agree that the HGS18 is a GREAT sub... particularly in the first octave! However, this system was built for my 93 yr. old mom and first octave stuff tends to rattle her osteoporodic bones. For real! I did a test with another 18 incher last year... it is a good thing that she has limited memory function... because she was really upset.
We just finished watching "Independence Day", re-running critical parts that exercise subwoofers using different configurations. The room has a lot of heavy drapes, upholstered valences, tapestries, massive upholstered furniture and a thick carpet. They soak up a lot of sonic energy that would otherwise be more damaging to the sound stage. Additionally, the three 12" subs are carefully positioned and phase switched to minimize cancellation. Just for the fun of it, I wanted to make this installation all Klipsch. Last year when I first built it there were no Klipsch speakers... who knows, thanks to you, Velodyne may just be next.
As you may recall from other posts, this experiment was to design a system that took advantage of an integrated loaded horn design to stimulate mom's neural pathways in a positive way. The three KSW-12's provide enough sonic orientation (without too much bone rattling)to heighten her awareness... without pushing her over to "Panicville." I keep the rear array on "LARGE" in order to skim of the lows for the KSW-12's. Actually, the KLF-10's do pretty well, but it takes a powered boost to make a statement when the rear channels are running discretely. The one KSW-15 in sync with the KLF-30's can rumble this room pretty well... though, obviously, not as pleasurably low as the Velodyne would go with the same material. Still, the object of this experiment is to see if I can get low range orientation effects and "in-sync" low range for discrete sounds not delivered to the primary subwoofer(s). Yes, I was running two 15" BASH subs and cut it down to balance the room with the rear array. As you can probably guess, under other conditions this rig would not be the same.
In any event, thanks for reminding me of something I shall try one of these days! HornEd