If you want to get technical, the O.C. material is still rigid and it is insulation... but i understand what you are saying. Like you said stryofoam wont work... This is kinda like the thought of going to buy a staight edge screw driver... its really called a standard screw driver... or going to get a saws-all... if you dont buy the actuall brand name saws-all it is just a reciprocating saw... we could get technical all day, but i have the feeling you knew what i was talking about.
But for me to clarify my own comments from earlier... I do NOT suggest to go out and by rigid styrofoam insulation... But i would suggest a rigid pressed fiberglass insulation.