Bob,
Glad to see you throwing your two cents into the mix. I am planning to get several of my componants from you, so yours is definitely an opinion I would like to have.
My consern was that the specs sheets I read showed the exact oposite. Atlas lists the PD-5VH as topping out at 4100 Hz (listed 110 - 4,100 Hz via atlas), while the D250-X is 9000 Hz (400-9000 Hz via parts express). That is what led me to opt for the D250-X in lieu of the Atlas, in order to provide a nice overlap cussion. Again this is all based on spec sheets, so I am very interested in real world comparisons.
Right now I am looking at the CW1526C and the CT125 for my top and bottom, with an upgraded crossover network, so I just want to be sure I have the right driver to fill that gap.
-Justin