I have been reading this thread with some interest. I am quite sure my response to all this will be unpopular!
While most if not all the charges levied here against the music business may be at least partially true, if not totally true, none of this negates the fact that downloading copyrighted music is nothing less than stealing.
It takes money away from the artists, no matter how SMALL a percentage that may sometimes be. It takes money out of the pockets of the recording engineers and the arrangers and the session musicians. (Few people realize how much of what you hear in a recording has to do with the recording engineers and not the artists). It also removes the motivation for new talent to spend the time practicing and honing their craft.
I am sure none of us here would be any less passionate about the companies we work for if they suddenly decided not to pay us for some of the days we work. (in essence stealing from us) Nor are we any less upset and pi**ed about having our car, money, stereo/HT equipment, dog, wife stolen.
So although we may have an intense dislike for the music industry, the people who RUN the industry and the quality of the product they serve up, we have no right to STEAL the material.