----------------
On 8/31/2004 10:05:09 PM jt1stcav wrote:
No problem, Erik. Everyone's experiences make for great reading, and in my limited knowledge, I also believe that changing driver and power tubes would probably make more sonic sense then the rectifier (not that it wouldn't also make a difference). But I still have a problem figuring out which GZ-series (if any) would be a best matchup for my amp, and I'm too chicken$hit to try for fear of frying the amp's innards! I did write to Edmund about my little dilemma, but as of yet I haven't received any response...Guess e-mail to Hong Kong is just as slow as the slow boat he uses to ship his gear over to these shores)!
----------------
jt,
You can use any tube with the 5T or 5L pinout with the exception of the 5AU4.
With your amplifier, the only real thing to watch out for is the filament current rating of the power transformer (which, in this case, is 3A 5V).
The 5AR4, 5U4, 5V4, 5Y3 and GZ equals can all be used without causing any damage. While switching between different types, there will be some voltage output variations, but nothing significant. For instance, compare the 5AR4 to the 5U4. Both will supply rated current without a problem, but the 5U4 drops slightly more voltage. The drop of the 5U4 is approx 50V, while the drop on the 5AR4 is approx 30V. A 20V difference in a tube rectified supply feeding tube stages is peanuts. You are not likely going to hear a difference.
The 20V difference is truly insignificant. Even two 5U4's made by the same manufacturer will not have identical voltage drops, there is a tolerance of 30% between identical types. Trying other types that have the same pinout and suitable current handling ratings is just fine. Rectifier tubes have such a wide tolerance that calibrating an amplifier to use a single type with a specified voltage output is impractical. If the tube used in calibration were replaced with another brand, or even the same brand, the voltage output value would have a variation up to 30% from the design center value.