scott r316 ? in 2-Channel Home Audio Posted March 23, 2010 Between the two, I'd go for the NAD over the Scott. But, that said, is there any way you can audition both with your speakers before you purchase? That's the only way to know for sure as there can be quite a difference in the sound. If you don't need the receiver section, look for a nice tube amp and you'll be much happier!