Jump to content

Vintage Mcintosh VS Sansui


Recommended Posts

Just thought I'd right my own little review based on my own experience.

I was Beating myself up because I listed all my mcintosh SS gear for sale and I have a buyer coming over tonight.......Soooo I pulled all my gear out and hooked it all up in the main listening room So I could A/B all the gear... I was listening through Heresy II's with new tweeters , BC recaps and then Cornwall I's BC recaps

For the gear Mcintosh : Mc 2505 , MX 112 fully serviced at Mcintosh a couple of years ago, MCD 7007

Sansui: Au 11000 just serviced, Au7900 serviced By Bristol 1 year ago, Au 7900 never serviced...Cheapo sony cd.....

And For Phono's Technics Sl1210.

Now I had had the Sansui gear hooked up for awhile and I was hesitant about hooking up the mac......turned on the mac with a very good Marcus Miller cd....boy was I relieved ....There was a definite dark veil over the mids and the bass was not responsive and crisp.

I went back and forth several times changing sources and speakers and the results were that even the unserviced Sansui AU 7900 was more musical and transparent. The Au 11000 just kicked butt ...Now i know it has double the headroom but we are talking and integrated that sells for about 1/3 of the mac gear I have.

The Mcintosh are pretty pieces, and I know they don't come close to some of the more modern megabucks units, but dollor for dollar the pre 1980 Sansui gear is highly underrated... and if you should happen to come across any at garage sales etc, try one out...they may surprise you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a MC 2205 amp, and wasn't impressed with it at all. Especially when comparing it to the VRD's. I tried it with an older Yamaha C4 preamp, as well as the BBX, and it just didn't deliver for me. I know there are others who really like the SS McIntosh sound, but I would have to say it's not for me.

Mike

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll get fried for this but I had a McIntosh MC-2102 which is a multi thousand dollar tubed amp. I sold it and replaced it with a pair of multi-hundred dollar Crown K2 amps and put $3,000 into my pocket. Although the 2102 DID sound good, it didn't sound $3,000 better to my ears than some other amps I have.

In my case, it was definately the law of diminishing returns and as much as I LOVED the look of that amp, "Mr. Practical" finally got ahold of me and I let it go.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It really is amazing that you can find very good inexpensive equipment if you have the right speakers!!! It kills me that most folks can't figure out that the speakers are over 50% of the equation. Some Speakers require that you drive them with 1000 plus watts and to what end??? spending MO money Mo money!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It really is amazing that you can find very good inexpensive equipment if you have the right speakers!!! It kills me that most folks can't figure out that the speakers are over 50% of the equation. Some Speakers require that you drive them with 1000 plus watts and to what end??? spending MO money Mo money!

I experienced that very equation with Maggies. They sounded nice with an MC2105, but they wanted more and I foolishly gave in till the checking account cried "Uncle!". Not to mention the savings reflected on the electric bill, and the lack of electric heaters that dominated my living landscape.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have read good things about the A50T.....heck hard to beat any simple EL34 amp!

Hey OB tubes are another story altogether........some classic Scott, dynaco gear will beat the pants off alot of the esoteric $20000 piles of gold plated ego out there.....as for me I'm getting my Klipschorns this weekend!!!! yeah baby and then I start looking hot and heavy for an original Sansui Au-111 6L6gc integrated...if not I'll "settle"[:D] for some VRDs...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It really is amazing that you can find very good inexpensive equipment if you have the right speakers!!! It kills me that most folks can't figure out that the speakers are over 50% of the equation. Some Speakers require that you drive them with 1000 plus watts and to what end??? spending MO money Mo money

[Y]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It really is amazing that you can find very good inexpensive equipment if you have the right speakers!!! It kills me that most folks can't figure out that the speakers are over 50% of the equation. Some Speakers require that you drive them with 1000 plus watts and to what end??? spending MO money Mo money!

[Y]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've yet to try my AU-717 w/horns, but have an AU-D9 at the ready and will try to get to it. An 1100 is desired eventually.

Previously a Yamaha CA-800 setup was ok, but the switch to the 5wpc EL-84 Almarro A205-A 'prototype' revealed things that I had not heard in the past (ever, dare I say, ever with headphones). Like Donald or Walter (or someone) singing WAY out of tune at the very (?) end of Steely Dan's Dr. Wu: "Can you hear me Dr.?".

It is between 3:49 and 3:51 on the cd track that I have if anyone wants to try. I have not tried it with the vinyl version yet.

Alas, the Almarro is 'polite' on bass by design, and will be the subject of their C1 mod in the near future to see what that changes.

Another mod, removing the coils, did certainly provide more HF extension - and it may have been after that when I heard what I heard.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a friend at work and some days all we debate are the danism's and silly nuances of the entire discograghy......

Caught the DR Wu thing a few years back on a really nice studio reference system, thanks for jolting my memory, I need to dig out the vinyl and check again ...I'm picking up a mint pair of klipschorns with ALK networks on saturday....I'll check it out on those puppies.

We are so nut's at work about Dan that when we have the money we want to do an "amazing race" type dan hunt.......going from city to city...we want to include all kinds of clues that if you don't get the reference and they can be littoral instead of figurative, you don't move on to get the next clue..... examples:

You need to outside the stadium at exactly 6:05 where there is a table full of cologne...and you need to pour out just the "brute" and "Charisma" on the shadow of "Hoops" only then can you proceed to my chow's to order the "schezwan dumplings" we came up with about 100 of these that could be linked....think it would be really cool!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...