Care to expand on that? Given DSD has the ability to carry even more information than analog tape, the ability to exceed the vinyl, with it's extreme limitations of dynamics, would be expected. I am assuming there are deficencies in the SACD. What are they?
Dave
Oh yes, I can expand on that.. I really didn't explain myself very well.
When I listen to my DSOTM SACD on my HT System, it does sound powerful and is an experience. I have been very pleased with the match up that I have with my McIntosh equipment and my Palladium speakers. Powerful is an understatement.
When I listen to vinyl, in this case, to DSOTM, I use my tube system. With DSOTM (and with most all other albums I play). When played with my McIntosh C2200 tube preamplifier, with two McIntosh 275 tube amp's, employing a pair of McIntosh XRT 18 speakers, the result is pretty impressive.
I conservatively use a Basis 1400 w/RB300 Tonearm/Incognito wired (Dynavector 10X5 MC) as my turntable for now. DSOTM sounds excellent every time I play it. No worries about analog limitations. For some reason, the XRT speakers, with those 32 tweeters, makes up for any shortcomings that analog technology may present. Vinyl played in this setting is hard to describe and very pleasing to hear.
In addition, when I play my vinyl DSOTM album, using my HT system with Palladium speakers (in two channel, with my Music Hall MMF-7/Pro-ject 9 Tonearm/Grado Platinum Cartridge) the end result is also remarkable.
I am not a convert to the thinking that DSD and its abilities is superior to analog (with its extreme limitations of dynamics). "It is what it is" and I like both. So, there you go.... I suppose it depends on how you hear it and how it is delivered to you, that is most important.
I see no deficencies in my SACD at this time.... "Play on...." Boxx