Jump to content

Neil Young's Pono


Tarheel

Recommended Posts

  • 5 months later...

My Pono player is due to arrive any day. I'll post a report.

As a Kickstarter supporter of this device, I've exchanged several emails with Pono support. My original query was whether the $299 black unit I purchased months ago would come with any music loaded. To my surprise and dismay, the answer was, "No," but music could be purchased from the Pono site after delivery. I replied that my confidence in the business wisdom of those backing Pono was shaken.

To send an empty unit is foolish. At least a sample tune from Neil Young was appropriate. Imagine the disappointment after receiving a silent player after all these months. I compared the scenario to the Monty Pyhton Dead Parrot bit. "That bird's dead. No it's not. Yes it is. No it's not." A dead bird can't sing,

It must have shamed them into sensibility. Pono recently announced that the Kickstarter units will now include a demo track from Neil Young. Of course it will. What were they thinking? Nobody had the sense to realize that delivering music-less players was absurd?

Edited by DizRotus
  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My Pono player is due to arrive any day. I'll post a report.

It must have shamed them into sensibility. Pono recently announced that the Kickstarter units will now include a demo track from Neil Young. Of course it will. What were they thinking? Nobody had the sense to realize that delivering music-less players was absurd?

 

Good for you for shaming then into doing the right thing.  One person can make a difference.  :emotion-21:

 

I hope you haven't bought into the modern version of the Betamax story.  I invested heavily in Betamax stuff because it had superior video and audio quality over VHS.  Did you ever try to rent a Betamax movie?  I couldn't, they didn't make them.  No one else could, either. Betamax then went quickly the way of the do-do bird.

 

Great equipment, no content. 

Edited by wvu80
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is what I'm trying to understand.  Where does the music that is supposed to sound so much better actually come from?  Is is up to the owner of the device to only put really good sounding music on the device?  What makes a PONO so great?  I'm just trying to understand.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It appears they have a web site that has music for sale

 

https://ponomusic.force.com/

 

Quote

 

Audio files can be loaded onto the PonoPlayer using the Pono Music Center desktop application (soon to be released on Windows and MacOS). The PonoPlayer can also be sideloaded as a USB storage device (Windows, MacOS, Linux).

Edited by joessportster
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It sounds like you have to buy "their" music for the whole concept to work...........and the player (PONO device) is just a good portable DAC.  I'm guessing.

Yep. A friend of mine came over yesterday with a portable FiiO X5 portable DAC that used up to two Micro SD cards for a total of 256 Gigs (128 per slot). It looked like a larger iPOD with rotary control. He had HD tracks on there that sounded mighty fine when plugged into a PCM digital input on my receiver. Most were 24/96. None were PONO proprietary. Only $349 at B&H

post-20774-0-74580000-1415048945_thumb.j

Edited by ClaudeJ1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess Ole' Neil hasn't told everyone if his new music library plays on other DACs that are as good or better than his little player.  I'm guessing that they don't.  I hope I'm wrong.  it would be good to have a library of such high quality tunes available.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good post Diz. I agree with every point. Just now I am playing a 180 gram Tom Waits/Crystal Gale LP, bought new and played maybe five times. I put it through the record vac twice, cleaned the stylus with the ZeroDust twice, used anti static brush, played it at perfect speed according to the strobe with an $800 dollar cartridge and still the grit sound remains. The recording is fantastic but the surface noise is distracting. Too many disc are like this....quiet ones are the exception.

I have a large LP collection but I long for the day some format surpasses the status quo.

 

The problem is that the music I like (and probably most of all the music you folks like too!!) will simply never be able to "become" ultra-high quality like Neil is suggesting.  Your music collection is probably as good as it is ever going to sound...........with rare exceptions of digital remasters that actually do sound better.

 

The point is.........going forward the PONO concept seems like a great thing to support...........it's just like 50 years too late for me.

 

That is why I simply got used to listening to the music I like..........regardless of sound quality...........rather than listen to some high quality recordings I could care less about just to hear my equipment and how nicely it can provide sound.  I'm past all that.  :)

 

When I run into a really nice recording of something I like..........well that is cool for sure. :)

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's my understanding that the Pono player will play other high resolution files from HDtracks, etc.  Conversely, I expect Pono music files can be played on other devices.  Only time will tell if one, both or neither of the foregoing is correct.

 

The first comment is supported by information on the Pono site regarding how to rip CDs to high resolution files for use on the Pono player.  Similarly, vinyl can be ripped to a high resolution file to be played from a computer or the Pono player.

 

I suspect the Pono player has a better than average DAC.  It will be interesting to compare high resolution FLAC files downloaded from HDtracks and now played on my Samsung S4 Android (which sound very good) to the same files played through my Pono player ( if it ever gets here), as well as comparing Pono files played on Pono to the HDtracks on the Android.

 

If there isn't a noticeable advantage to the Pono player, a one owner low mileage black Pono might be available for quick delivery.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Good post Diz. I agree with every point. Just now I am playing a 180 gram Tom Waits/Crystal Gale LP, bought new and played maybe five times. I put it through the record vac twice, cleaned the stylus with the ZeroDust twice, used anti static brush, played it at perfect speed according to the strobe with an $800 dollar cartridge and still the grit sound remains. The recording is fantastic but the surface noise is distracting. Too many disc are like this....quiet ones are the exception.

I have a large LP collection but I long for the day some format surpasses the status quo.

 

The problem is that the music I like (and probably most of all the music you folks like too!!) will simply never be able to "become" ultra-high quality like Neil is suggesting.  Your music collection is probably as good as it is ever going to sound...........with rare exceptions of digital remasters that actually do sound better.

 

The point is.........going forward the PONO concept seems like a great thing to support...........it's just like 50 years too late for me.

 

That is why I simply got used to listening to the music I like..........regardless of sound quality...........rather than listen to some high quality recordings I could care less about just to hear my equipment and how nicely it can provide sound.  I'm past all that.  :)

 

When I run into a really nice recording of something I like..........well that is cool for sure. :)

 

Pono music is digitally remastered from the original untouched masters (pre cd mix). This is what we were told at a private demo.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...